Journal of Food Science & Nutrition Category: Agriculture Type: Research Article

Nutritional and Sensory Properties of Cookies Produced from Flour Blends of African Walnut (Tetracarpidium Conophorum), Justicia Carnea and Wheat

Udedeh H Emem1, Nkechi JT Emelike1, Chinasa Okorie-Humphrey2 and Chukwunwike Uchenna Enyi3*
1 Department of food science and technology, Faculty of Agriculture, Rivers State University P.M.B 5080 Port Harcourt, Rivers State, Nigeria
2 Department of food science and technology, College of Applied Food Sciences and Tourism, Michael Okpara University of Agriculture Umudike P.M.B 7267 Umuahia, Abia State, Nigeria
3 Department of food science and technology, University of Agriculture and Environmental Science Umuagwo, Imo State, Nigeria

*Corresponding Author(s):
Chukwunwike Uchenna Enyi
Department Of Food Science And Technology, University Of Agriculture And Environmental Science Umuagwo, Imo State, Nigeria
Email:nnasedo@gmail.com

Received Date: Jun 05, 2024
Accepted Date: Jul 04, 2024
Published Date: Jul 12, 2024

Abstract

This study aims to evaluate the nutritional and sensory properties of cookies produced from flour blends of African walnut (Tetracarpidium conophorum), Justicia carnea and wheat. 

Walnut flour was used to substitute wheat flour while the Justicia carnea flour was used at a constant percentage as an enrichment in the ratio of (A) 100:00:0 (B) 88:10:2 (C) 78:20:2 (D) 68:30:2 of Wheat, walnut and Justicia carnea. Proximate composition of the cookies ranged between 0.65-1.45% for moisture, 2.15-2.80% for ash, 22.44-29.07% for fat, 9.19-11.25% for protein, 4.88-7.66% for crude fiber and 50.37-59.98% for carbohydrate. Moisture content decreased significantly (P < 0.05) as walnut substitution increased while fat, protein, crude fiber and ash content increased as walnut substitution increased. The functional properties showed that water and oil absorption capacities ranged between 0.56-1.19 ml/g and 0.59-1.27ml/g respectively. Bulk density from 0.68-0.79ml/g, solubility and swelling power from 14.95-17.89% and 6.53-7.57g/g respectively. 

Mineral composition for Sodium, Potassium, Magnesium, Calcium and Phosphorus ranged between 465.16-507.29mg/100g, 176.36-436.36mg/100g, 16.60-89.86mg/100, 23.69-60.80mg/100g and 9.40-11.40mg/100g respectively. Sodium, Potassium, magnesium and Phosphorus contents increased significantly (P < 0.05) while Calcium decreased with increase in walnut flour substitution. The physical properties ranged between 0.50-0.60cm, 5.45-5.50cm and 9.16-10.80cm for height, diameter and spread ratio respectively. Only sample D showed significant increase (P < 0.05) in spread ratio. Sensory scores showed crumb colour, crust thickness, crumb homogeneity, crumb moisture, crumb cohesiveness, fresh cookies odour, crumb consistency and overall acceptability reduced with increase in walnut flour. The study revealed that nutritious and acceptable cookies could be produced from addition of African walnut and Justicia carnea flour blend.

Keywords

African walnut; Cookies; Justicia carnea; Proximate composition; Wheat

Introduction

Cookies are known snacks that can be widely eaten by people of all class and age. It is a baked product that is made from flour, water, fat, and sugar. Wheat flour is used as the main ingredient for cookies production due to gluten not present in other cereals. Cookies have some advantages compared with other snacks as they are cheaper, good shelf life, and are available in different sizes, tastes, colors, and packs [1]. They are readily available for consumption, convenient and inexpensive food products which contain digestive and dietary principles of vital importance [2]. Cookies are high nutritional snacks produced from dough that is transformed into appetizing products by baking in the oven at a particular temperature. Majority of these food products are poor source of protein and micronutrients [3]. 

African walnut (Tetracarpidinum conophorum) is underused crop which is rich in phenolic compounds [4]. The kernels of African walnut are sources of oil and the cake removed after extraction of the oil contains protein [5]. Uhunmwangho and Omoregie [6], carried a research on the nutrition and anti-nutrition contents of walnut seed oil at various phases of fruit maturation. This investigation revealed the nourishing profile of the fruit-nut of walnut as a good source of plant protein, carbohydrate and fat, with a decrease in the degree of some anti-nutrients in matured fruits. Due, to, the high protein quality of the seeds including higher levels of essential amino acids, other nutrients and phytochemicals when compared to other nuts, it could be used in the development of functional foods [7]. The kernel is rich in vitamins and mineral. The utilization of the seeds have been further enhance by different researches carried out on the use of processed African walnut flour in bread production [8], and biscuit [9]. 

Justicia carnea is a medicinal plant reported to have multiple pharmacological benefits, including blood-boosting potential. Locally, J. carnea species are being used in the treatment of respiratory tract infection, inflammation, gastrointestinal disease, rheumatism and arthritis [10]. Due to the function they perform on the central nervous system, they are used as depressors, hallucinogens, sedatives and treatment for epilepsy, somniferous agents and mental disorders [10]. J. carnea leaves extract are rich in iron, riboflavin, vitamin A, C, E, B1, B2, B9 and B12 [11]. Wheat grains are usually used in processing a wide variety of food products [12]. Wheat grains is rich in carbohydrate, it contains significant amounts of other essential nutrients like proteins and minor components like vitamins, lipids, minerals and phytochemicals [12]. Two major groups of phytochemicals gotten from various biosynthetic pathways such as phenolics and terpenoids can be found in wheat grain [12]. The antioxidant properties of wheat have been linked to its phenolic phytochemicals such as alkylresorcinals, hydroxycinnamic acids [13]. This is evidence that wheat can really be used as the basis for development of functional foods made to enhance the health of millions of consumers [14]. 

Malnutrition leads to a poor health condition resulting from insufficient or unbalanced consumption of nutrients which pose as a problem in developing countries like Nigeria [15]. Majority of these products consumed by both children and adults are mostly low in protein and micro-nutrients. Due to insufficient knowledge of the availability of some of these local tree nuts and leaves or its nutritional characteristics, they are usually neglected and as a result have not been utilized to its fullest potential. Therefore this study is being carried out in other to explore these under-utilized plant produce in cookies production. The objective of this study is to evaluate the nutritional and sensory properties of cookies produced from flour blends of African walnut (T. conophorum), J. carnea and wheat.

Materials and Methods

Sources of raw materials 

African walnut, (T. conophorum) was purchased from Fruit Garden Market, Port Harcourt, Rivers State. Other ingredient which include wheat flour, sugar and salt (Dangote), baking powder (Longman), Margarine (Pomo), Milk (Dano), Vanilla flavour and eggs were bought at Mile 3 Oroworokwu Market, Port Harcourt. J. Carnea was gotten from D/line, Port Harcourt. 

Preparation of Raw Materials 

The African walnut (T. conophorum) was prepared according to the method by Noha and Almoraise [16]. The raw material was sorted and washed with clean water to remove unwanted materials and then cooked for 1 hour. The walnut was sliced to increase surface area. The sliced walnut was blanched in hot water for 5 minutes and dried in hot air oven (DHG-9140A Shanghai China) at 60°C for 24 hours after which it was grounded into flour with an attrition mill (Globe P14 Shanghai China) and was sieved to obtain African walnut flour. The flour was packaged in an air tight container until needed for analysis.

J.carnea was prepared according to the method by Otuokere et al. [17], with slight modification. raw material was sorted, washed and dried in an oven (DHG-9140A Shanghai China) at 50°C for 24 hours and was milled into flour with an attrition mill (Globe P14 Shanghai China) and sieved to obtain J. carnea flour. The flour was packaged in an air tight container until needed for analysis. 

Formulation of Flour Blends 

Wheat, African walnut and J. carnea flours were mixed at different proportion 88:10:2, 78:20:2, 68:30:2 while 100% wheat served as control (Tables 1 & 2). 

Sample Code

Flour Sample

African Walnut Flour

Wheat Flour

J. Carnea

A (0AWF:100WF:0JCF)

0

100

0

B (10AWF:88WF:2JCF)

10

88

2

C (20AWF:78WF:2JCF)

20

78

2

D (30AWF:68WF:2CF)

30

68

2

Table 1: Composition of wheat, African walnut and J. carnea flours. 

Ingredients

A

B

C

D

Wheat flour (g)

100

88

78

68

Justicia, carnea (g)

-

2

2

2

Walnut flour (g)

-

10

20

30

Margarine (g)

50

50

50

50

Sugar (g)

25

25

25

25

Whole egg

1

1

1

1

Vanilla(ml)

5

5

5

5

Baking powder (g)

2

2

2

2

Water(ml)

10

10

10

10

Salt (g)

0.4

0.4

0.4

0.4

Table 2: Formulation of composite flour for cookies production. 

Preparation of Cookies 

Cookies were produced according to the method described by Barber and Emelike [18], with some modifications. Walnut flour substituted Wheat flour at levels 10%, 20% and 30%. The Margarine and Sugar were homogenized using a master chef mixer at medium speed. Composite flour, whole egg, sifted dry ingredients, vanilla essence and water were added to the mixture and homogenized thoroughly until dough is formed. The dough was rolled on a flat surface before using a circular cutter to cut out the cookies which were then baked in a preheated oven at 175°C for 15 minutes. The cookies were then removed from the oven, allowed to cool before being packaged in an airtight container. 

Determination of Functional Properties of Cookies Sample 

Bulk density, water absorption capacity, oil absorption capacity, solubility and swelling index and least gelation concentration were all determined according to the method of AOAC [19]. 

Determination of Proximate Compositions of Cookies Sample 

Moisture content, crude protein, Crude fiber, fat, ash content and carbohydrate were all determined according to the method of AOAC [19]. 

Determination of Mineral Compositions of Cookies Sample 

Calcium (Ca) and Magnesium (Mg) contents of the samples were determined according to the method of Carpenter and Hendricks [20]. Sodium (Na) and potassium (K) contents were determined by flame photometry method as described by James [21]. Phosphorus (P) was determined by spectrophotometry method. 

Determination of Physical Properties of Cookies Sample 

Height, diameter and spread ratio were determined according to the method of AOAC [22]. 

Sensory Evaluation of Cookies Sample 

The sensory evaluation was determined according to the method of Iwe [23]. 

Data Analysis 

Significant differences (p < 0.05) among treatment means were determine by analysis of variance. Mean separation was carried out using SPSS version 22.0. Separation of means was carried out by Duncan Multiple range test and values were reported as means and standard deviation.

Results

Functional Properties of Wheat, African Walnut and J. Carnea Composite Flours 

The functional properties of wheat, African walnut and J. carnea composite flour are shown in table 3. Water absorption capacity of the flour ranged from 0.56%-1.19% as 100% wheat (A) recorded the lowest while 30% walnut substitute (D) recording the highest. The control cookie deferred significantly (P <0.05) from the other samples. Oil absorption capacity ranged between 0.59%-1.27% as sample (A) recorded the lowest and sample (D) recorded the highest. There was significant difference (P <0.05) in Oil absorption capacity between sample A and Sample D. Bulk density ranged from 0.68%-0.79g/m as sample D and sample A recorded the lowest and highest value respectively. There was significant difference (P <0.05) between sample A and the rest of the samples. Result showed that solubility ranged between 14.9%-17.8% as 10% walnut substitute (B) recorded the lowest and 20% walnut substitute (C) recorded the highest. There was no significant difference (P>0.05) within the substituted samples. Swelling power of the samples ranged from 6.53-7.57% as sample D and sample A recorded the lowest and the highest value respectively. Results showed a significant difference between sample A and sample D. The least gelation concentration of the samples was 2.00% with all samples having the same value.

Sample Code

 

Water Absorption

(%)

Oil Absorption

(%)

Bulk Density

(g/ml)

Swelling power %

Solubility %

Least gelation %

 
 

A(0AWF:100WF:0JCF)

0.56+0.00b

0.59+0.00a

0.79+0.00a

7.57+0.20a

7.42+ 0.82ab

2.00+0.00a

 

B(10AWF:88WF:2JCF)

0.88+0.15ab

0.78+0.01b

0.78+0.01b

7.42+0.82ab

14.95+ 0.42a

2.00+ 0.00a

 

C(20AWF:78WF:2JCF)

1.18+0.00a

0.89+0.14ab

0.71+0.00bc

7.02+0.00ab

16.76+ 2.17a

2.00+0.00a

 

D(30AWF:68WF:2CF)

1.19+0.00a

1.27+0.12a

0.68+0.01c

6.53+0.40b

16.44+ 1.03a

2.00+0.00a

 

Table 3: Functional properties of Wheat, African walnut and J. carnea flour blends. 

Note: Values are mean +Standard deviation of triplicate determinations. Means with the same superscript in the same column are not significantly (P>0.05) different.

Proximate Composition of Cookies Produced from Wheat, African Walnut and J. Carnea Flour Blends

The proximate compositions of cookies from wheat, African walnut and J. carnea flour blends are shown in table 4. The result showed that moisture content of the samples ranged between 0.65% - 1.45% as sample D recorded the lowest while sample A recorded the highest. There was significant difference (P <0.05) in moisture content of samples A and D. Addition of walnut significantly increased the protein, ash, fat and fibre content of the cookies. The ash content ranged from 1.60%-2.80% as sample D recorded the lowest while sample C recorded the highest. There was significant difference in the ash content between samples D and A. The fats contents of the cookies ranged from 22.44%-29.07% as samples D and A recorded the highest and lowest values respectively. The protein content of the sample ranged between 9.19%-11.25% as sample A recorded the lowest while sample D recorded the highest. The crude fibre content of the sample ranged from 4.88%-7.37% as sample A recorded the lowest while sample B recorded the highest. The carbohydrate content of the cookies ranged from 50.37%-59.98%. There was no significant difference (P>0.05) in the carbohydrate content within the samples.

Sample Code (%)

Moisture

Ash

Fat

Protein

Fiber

Carbohydrate

A(0AWF:100WF:0JCF)

1.45+0.07a

2.15+0.07b

22.44+0.73b

9.19+0.00b

4.88+0.43b

59.98+0.88a

B(10AWF:88WF:2JCF)

1.16+0.03b

2.49+0.14a

23.29+0.45b

9.56+0.00b

7.66+0.73a

55.86+0.34a

C(20AWF:78WF:2JCF)

1.32+0.02ab

2.80+0.00a

27.55+0.77a

10.59+0.30ab

7.37+0.24a

50.37+1.34a

D(30AWF:68WF:2CF)

0.65+0.00c

2.60+0.00a

29.07+0.67a

11.25+0.62a

5.18+0.55b

51.00+0.86a

Table 4: Proximate composition of cookies made from wheat, African walnut and J.carnea flours. 

Note: Values are mean +Standard deviation of triplicate determinations. Means with the same superscript in the same column are not significantly (P>0.05) different.

Mineral Compositions of Cookies Produced from Wheat, African Walnut and J. Carnea Flour Blends 

The mineral compositions of cookies from wheat, African walnut and J. carnea flour blends are shown in table 5. Sodium content of the cookies ranged between 465.16-507.29mg/100g as sample B recorded the lowest value while C recorded the highest. There was significance difference in the sodium content of the samples. Potassium and magnesium contents ranged from 176.36-436.36mg/100g and 16.60-89.86mg/100g for samples A and D respectively. Result showed that potassium and magnesium increased significantly (P <0.05) with increase in walnut substitution. Calcium content of the cookies ranged from 23.69-60.80mg/100g as samples B and A recorded lowest and highest respectively. Phosphorus content of the cookies ranged from 9.40- 11.0mg/100g as sample A recorded the lowest while 10% walnut substitute recorded the highest.

Sample Code

Na

K

Mg

Ca

P

A(0AWF:100WF:0JCF)

466.60+ 0.14c

176.36+ 0.00d

16.60+ 0.00d

60.80+ 0.14a

9.40+ 0.00b

B(10AWF:88WF:2JCF)

465.16 + 0.00c

315.11+ 1.41c

47.00+ 1.41c

23.69+ 0.00d

11.40+ 0.00b

C(20AWF:78WF:2JCF)

507.29 +1.41a

402.04+ 0.00b

76.10+ 0.14b

45.37+ 0.14c

10.40+ 0.01c

D(30AWF:68WF:2CF)

496.16 + 0.14a

436.36+ 0.42c

89.86+ 0.04a

49.56+ 0.04b

11.00+ 0.00b

Table 5: Mineral composition of cookies made from wheat, African walnut and J. carnea flour blends (mg/100g). 

Note: Values are mean +Standard deviation of triplicate determinations. Means with the same superscript in the same column are not significantly (P>0.05) different.

Physical Properties of Cookies Produced from Wheat, African Walnut and J. Carnea Composite Flour 

The physical properties of cookies from wheat, African walnut and J. carnea flour blends are shown in table 6. The height of the cookies ranged from 0.50-0.60cm as sample D recorded the lowest while Samples A, B and C recorded the highest. Only Sample D showed significant difference (P < 0.05) compared to the other samples. The diameter of the cookies ranged between 5.4-5.5cm as Samples D and A recorded the lowest and the highest values respectively. There was no significant difference in diameter of the cookies. The spread ratio of the cookies ranged between 9.16-10.80m/m as Sample D recorded the highest. Result showed that the spread ratio of sample D was significantly different (P < 0.05) from the rest of the samples.

Sample Code

Height (cm)

Diameter (cm)

Spread Ratio (m/m)

A(0AWF:100WF:0JCF)

0.60 + 0.00a

5.50 + 0.00a

9.16 + 0.00b

B(10AWF:88WF:2JCF)

0.60 + 0.00a

5.50 + 0.00a

9.16 + 0.00b

C(20AWF:78WF:2JCF)

0.60 + 0.00a

5.45 + 0.00a

9.16 + 0.00b

D(30AWF:68WF:2CF)

0.50 + 0.00b

5.40 + 0.00a

10.80 + 0.00a

Table 6: Physical properties of cookies produced from wheat, African walnut and J. carnea flour blends. 

Note: Values are mean +Standard deviation of triplicate determinations. Means with the same superscript in the same column are not significantly (P>0.05) different.

Sensory Properties of Cookies Produced from Wheat, African Walnut, and J. Carnea Flour Blends 

The sensory properties of cookies from wheat, African walnut and J. carnea flour blends are shown in figure 1. The score for crumb colour ranged from 3.45-4.65% as sample A recorded the lowest while sample D recorded the highest. The result showed there was significant difference (P < 0.05) between sample A and the rest of the samples. The crust thickness ranged from 2.75-3.45% as sample B recorded the lowest while sample D recorded the highest. Result showed a significant difference in crumb thickness within the samples. Crumb Homogeneity ranged from 2.85-3.15% as samples C and D recorded the lowest while sample A recorded the highest. Crumb moisture ranged between 1.65-2.2% as sample A recorded the lowest while sample C recorded the highest. Crumb cohesiveness ranged from 2.85-3.00% as sample D scored the lowest while sample A scored the highest. There was no significant difference (P>0.05) in the samples. Fresh cookies odour ranged between 2.70-3.4% with sample D scoring the lowest while sample A scored the highest. Crumb consistency ranged from 2.95-3.20 as sample C scored the highest. Overall acceptability of the cookies ranged from 3.1-3.40% as samples C and A scored the lowest and highest respectively.

 Figure 1: Sensory properties of cookies produced from wheat, African walnut, and J. carnea flour blends. 

Discussion

From table 3, water absorption capacity of the composite flour blend of African walnut, wheat and J. carnea flour ranged between 0.56-1.19%. A similar result was reported by Eke-Ejiofor and Kporna [24], on cowpea and Acha composite from (1.20-1.36%). The increase observed in water absorption capacity may be as a result of increase in the protein solubility due to the addition of walnuts which protein is known for its high solubility and assumption capacity [16]. The high water absorption capacity of wheat and walnut is an indication that the flour may find application in food preparation where water absorption is needed. Granito et al. [25], reported that water absorption capacity is regarded as a function property of proteins which may beneficial in viscous food like soup sauces, dough and in baked food products where good protein-water interaction is required. 

Oil absorption Capacity of Wheat, Walnut and J. carnea composite flour significantly increased (P < 0.05) showing higher value of oil absorption capacity amongst samples as Walnut substitution increased. The oil absorption capacity was lower when compared with cowpea-acha composite flour as reported by Eke-Ejiofor and Kporna [24]. According to the result obtained, increase in the substitution of walnut flour resulted in an increase in the oil absorption capacity which may be as a result of the availability of surface hydrophobic proteins and non-polar side chain which play major role in binding of oil [26]. High oil absorption capacity is useful in food applications mostly in flavor retention enhancement and reduction of moisture and fat loss which helps to prolong the shelf life of meat products [16]. There is a decrease with increased substitute of the walnut flour. 

Low bulk density of the blends is beneficial in the formulation of baby food which requires high nutrient density to low bulk [27]. The result show that walnut flour has low bulk density and this may be as a result of availability of oil in the sample. Bulk density shows the volume of packaging material that is needed to transport the food product. Bulk density reduces porosity of materials due to surface properties [27]. 

There was a significant decrease (P < 0.05) in swelling power as walnut substitute increased. Higher protein content in flour may affect the starch granule as it could cause it to be embedded within a stiff protein matrix, which will reduce the intake of water by starch thereby restrict the swelling power [28]. There was no significant (P>0.05) effect on the solubility of the flours. There was a decrease in solubility of the flours as the walnut substitute increase. This may be as a result of low water binding ability of walnut flour available in the oil. 

From table 4, the variation in moisture content is below the accepted moisture contents of dry food (not more 9% for flour blends) [16]. The addition of walnut to wheat flour affected the binding of moisture as a result, the composite cookies had a reduced moisture content. The low moisture content is important in preventing microbial growth and extending the shell-life of cookies. This could be achieved if the product is protected from absorbing moisture through proper packaging. 

The Ash content of the cookies was significantly higher (P < 0.05) with increase in walnut substitution which could be due to the high ash content of walnut flour. The high ash content of cookies indicates high mineral content. Ash content value from this study is lower than that of tigernut-maize flour blend cookies which ranged from 2.03-3.38% reported by Obinna-echem and Robinson [29]. The current finding is in agreement with the result of Aleem et al. [30], who reported an increase in ash content (0.69-2.01%) for wheat-defatted soya bean cookies. 

The fat content increased with increase in walnut flour substitution. Sample A (100% wheat flour) had significantly lower (P < 0.05) fat content than Sample D (with 30% walnut flour). This pose, as a problem of rancidity during storage, although fat enhances the absorption of fat soluble vitamin, improves mouthful and retains flavor [31]. 

The protein values of the cookies are similar to those of commercially available biscuits in Nigeria like Top biscuit by Parle [32]. The protein values of the cookies are within the values of tigernut-maize flour cookies reported by Obinna-echem and Robinson [29]. The cookies from 100% wheat flour had the lowest protein with significant increase in the protein level as walnut substitution increased. This may be due to the high protein content of walnut flour as compared to wheat flour. 

Fiber ranged between 4.88 (100% wheat flour) to 7.66 (10% walnut flour) with increase recorded at each level of substitution indicating high dietary fiber in walnut flour. Crude fiber is beneficial in the enhanced utilization of nitrogen and absorption of some other micronutrients and provides bulk which is important for peristaltic action in the intestinal tract [29]. The result showed that an increase in walnut substitution resulted in an increase in crude fiber and this may as a result of high crude fiber content of walnut as compared to wheat. 

The carbohydrate content of walnut-wheat cookies is similar to some of the commercially available cookies in Nigeria [32]. The carbohydrate content was significantly (P < 0.05) lower than the carbohydrate content of tigernut-maize based cookies reported by Obinna-echem and Robinson [29]. It was observed that there was a decrease in carbohydrate content of the samples as the walnut substitution increased. This may due to the decrease in the percentage of carbohydrate rich wheat flour. 

The levels of the minerals; sodium, potassium, magnesium and phosphorous increased with increase in substitution of walnut flour except calcium. The increase in the mineral content of the flour blend cookies confirms the importance of supplementation. The control (100% wheat flour) had significantly (P < 0.05) the least value with increased value of sodium as the walnut substitution increased. Low sodium level in the blood can result to Hyponatremia [33]. The level of potassium in samples varied significantly (P < 0.05) with highest value in Sample D. Potassium assist in regulating muscle contractions, fluid balance and nerve signals. It also prevents osteoporosis and reduces blood pressure [34]. Cookies from the composite flours blends had higher magnesium when compared with the control sample. This is an indication that African walnut and J. carnea are rich in magnesium. Magnesium is associated with over 300 metabolic reactions and it is beneficial in bone formation, new cells production, blood clothing, activation of B vitamins, relaxing navies and muscle and energy production [35]. A decrease in calcium was recorded as the walnut substitution increased. Calcium is beneficial in the growth and development of infant and young children. Phosphorous plays a vital role in every living cell. It is very important in bone formation and other cellular reactions in the body [36]. There was an increase in potassium as walnut substitution increase.

The height of the cookies varied significantly (P < 0.05) for sample D while sample A, B and C were not significantly different (P>0.05). There was no significant difference (P>0.05) in the diameter of the cookies. This shows uniform elasticity of the dough and even thermal expansion during baking. The spread ratio is known for the ratio of the diameter to the height. Having higher spread ratios are consider most desirable. Singh et al. [37], reported that the spread ratio of cookies increased as non-wheat protein ratio increased. The spread ratio of the cookies increased significantly (P < 0.05) with an increase in walnut flour. Higher spread ratio is preferred as reductions are attributed to the hydrophilic nature of flours [38]. 

From figure 1, the control (100% wheat cookies) had the highest score for the overall acceptability but there was no significant difference (P>0.05) among other samples for the attributes of crumb colour. The result showed the decrease in acceptability of cookies as walnut substitution increased. Barber and Obinna-Echem [39], reported similar values when Walnut was substituted. There was no significant difference in crumb colour for the substituted samples. This is due to the constant ratio of J. carnea flour. Generally, panelist preferred cookies formulated with 88% flour, 10% African walnut flour and 2% J. carnea flour.

Conclusion

The study revealed that nutritious and acceptable cookies could be produced from addition of African walnut and J. carnea flour blend. The substitution of African walnut and J. carnea produced nutritionally superior cookies, though the control (100% wheat flour) was the most acceptable organoleptically. The use of wheat /African, walnut /J. carnea composite flour in the production of cookies significantly (P < 0.05) improved the protein fat ash, crude fiver, sodium phosphorus, potassium and magnesium as compared to the control. The physical parameter (diameter, height and spread ratio) were comparable with some produced commercially. This result can help combat the high occurrence of malnutrition in children in Nigeria and other developing countries. It is necessary that we explore the use of non-wheat flour to enhance the nutritional value of staple snacks like cookies.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors report no conflicts of interests.

References

  1. Al-Marazeeq KM, Angor MM (2017) Chemical characteristic and sensory evaluation of biscuit enriched with wheat germ and the effect of storage time on the sensory properties for this product. Food Nutr Sci 8: 189-195.
  2. Obasi NE, Uchechukwu N, Eke-Obia E (2012) Production and evaluation of biscuits from African yam bean (sphenostyllis stenocarpa) and wheat (Triticumae stivum) flour. Food Science Journal 7: 5-12.
  3. Akpuaka MU, Nwankwo E (2000) Extraction, analysis and utilization of a drying oil from Tetracarpidium conophorum. Journal of Bioscience and Technology 73: 195-196.
  4. Prasad RBN (2003) Walnuts and Pecans. Encyclopedia of Food Sciences and Nutrition 2: 6071-6079.
  5. Awofadeju OFJ (2020) Evaluation of protein quality in blends prepared from commercial wheat (Triticum aestivum) and yellow maize flours (Zea mays) and African walnut (Tetracarpidium conophorum) protein isolate. Euro. Modern Studies J 4: 113-129.
  6. Uhunmwangho ES, Omoregie ES (2017) Evaluation of nutritive, anti-nutritive and mineral content of Tetracarpidium conophorum (African Walnut) seed oil at different stages of fruit maturation. Haya: Saudi Journal of Life Sciences 2: 210-216.
  7. Oladiji AT, Abodunrin TP, Yakubu MT (2010) Toxicological evaluation of Tetracarpidium conophorum nut oil-based diet in rats. Food Chemical Toxicology 48: 898-902.
  8. Awofadeju OFJ, Awe AB, Adewunmi OJ, Ogidan EA, Ojo AF, et al. (2018) Physicochemical, nutritional and consumers acceptability of bread made from wheat flour enriched with African walnut flour. J Forestry Res Manage 15: 184-194.
  9. Olapade AA, Abu OM (2019) Evaluation of blends of wheat (Triticum aestivum) flour and African walnut (Tetracarpidium conophorum) flour in biscuit production. Cro J Food Sci Tech 11: 245-250.
  10. Faiza R, Waqas KK, Adeel M, Muhammad G (2013) Detection of bioactive fractions of Justicia carnea Canadian Journal of Applied Science 1: 388-398.
  11. Onyeabo C, Achi K, Ekeleme-Egedigwe EA, Chima U, Okoro CK (2017) Haematological and biochemical studies of Justicia carnea leaves extract in phenylhydrazine induced anemia in albino rats. Journal of Food Sciences and Nutrition 16: 217-230.
  12. Shewry PR, Hey SJ (2015) The contribution of wheat to human diet and health. Food Energy secur 4: 178-202.
  13. Gayathri D, Rashmi BS (2016) Critical analysis of wheat as food. Matern Pediatr Nutr 2: 115.
  14. Kosík T, Lacko-Bartošová M, Kobida L (2014) Free phenol content and antioxidant activity of winter wheat in sustainable farming systems. Journal of Microbiology, Biotechnology and Food Sciences 3: 247-249.
  15. Tapsell CL, David RJ, Myron DG (2009) Food synergy: An operational concept for understanding nutrition. Am J Clin Nutr 89: 15433-15485.
  16. Noha MA, Almoraise (2019) The Effect of Walnut Flour on the Physical and Sensory Characteristics of Wheat Bread. International Journal of Food Science 7.
  17. Otuokere IE, Amaku AJ, Igwe K, Chinedum GC (2016) Medicinal Studies on the Phytochemical Constituents of Justicia carnea by GC-MS. American Journal of Science and Health 2: 71-77.
  18. Barber LI, Emelike NJT, Sunday BN (2016) Utilization of Breadfruit in Low fat cookie formulation. Journal of Food and Nutrition Research 4: 658-663.
  19. AOAC (2012) Official Method of Analysis. Association of Official Analytical Chemists, Washington DC, USA.
  20. Carpenter CE, Hendrick DG (2003) Mineral analysis. In: Food.
  21. James CS (1998) Analytical chemistry of food. Chapman and Hall, London, UK.
  22. AOAC (2004) Official Methods of Analysis of the Association of Official Analytical Chemists. Association of Official Analytical Chemists, Washington DC, USA.
  23. Iwe MO (2000) Handbook of Sensory methods and analysis. Projoint Communications Services Ltd, Enugu,
  24. Eke-Ejiofor J, Kporna JD (2019) Nutrient and Sensory Evaluation of Cowpea-Acha Flour Blend in pudding production. Food Science Nutritional Technology 4: 000174.
  25. Granito M, Guerrera M, Torres A, Guimand J (2004) Efecto del Procesanieto Sobre Las Propiedades functionals de digma simensis. Imteviciencia 29: 521-526
  26. Benitez V, Cantera S, Yol A, Esperanza M, Rosa ME, et al. (2013) Impact of germination on Starch dietary fiber and physiochemical properties in non-conventional legumes. Food Research International 50: 64-69.
  27. Olapade AA, Aworth OC (2012) Evaluation of extruded snacks from blends of Acha (Digitariaexillis) and cowpea (Vignaun guiculata) flours. International Journal of Agricultural Engineering 14: 210-217.
  28. Aprianita A, Purwandari U, Watson B, Vazijevic T (2009) Physicochemical Properties of Flour and Starches from Selected commercial Tubers available in Australia. International Food Research Journal 16: 507-520.
  29. Obinna-echem PC, Robinson ES (2019) Proximate composition, physical and sensory properties of biscuits produced from blends of maize (Zea mays) and tigernut (Cyperus esculentus) flour. Sky Journal of Food Science 7: 30-36.
  30. Aleem-Zaker MDI, Genitha TRI, Syed IH (2012) Effect of defatted Soy flour incorporation on Physical, Sensorial and Nutritional properties of Biscuits. Journal Food Process Technology 34: 54-57.
  31. Buransompob A, Tang J, Mao R, Barry GS (2007) Rancidity of Walnuts and Almonds affected by short time heat treatments for Insect Control. Journal of food processing and preservation 27: 445-464.
  32. Musa A, Lawal T (2013) Proximate composition of Ten types of Biscuits and their susceptibility to Tribolium castaneum Herbs (Tenebrionidae Bostrichidae) in Nigeria. Food Science 14: 33-40.
  33. Ijeomah AU, Uguwoma FU, Ibrahim Y (2012) Nutrient composition of three commonly consumed indigenous vegetables of North-Central Nigeria Journal of Agriculture, Food and Environmental 8: 17-21.
  34. Kanu P, Aggarwal SN, Monica K (2013) Molecular Mechanism of Renal stone formation and the critical role played by modulators. Journal of Biomedical Research International 10: 11-55.
  35. Guerrera MP, Stella LV, Jun JM (2009) Therapeutic uses of magnesium. Am Fam Physician 80: 157-162.
  36. Ndie EC, Nnamani CV, Oselebe HO (2010) Some physicochemical characteristics of Defatted plants derived from African walnut (Tetracarpidium conophorum). An underutilized legume. Pakistan Journal of Nutrition 9: 909-911.
  37. Singh R, Singh G, Chauchan GS (2003) Nutritional Evaluation of Soy fortified Biscuits. Journal of Food Science and Technology 37: 162-164.
  38. Okpala L, Okoli E, Udensi E (2013) Physico-chemical and Sensory Properties of Cookies made from Blends of Germinated Pigeon Pea, ferment sorghum, and cocoyam flours. Food Sci Nutr 1: 8-14.
  39. Barber IC, Obinna-Echem PC (2016) Nutrient Composition, Physical and Sensory Properties of wheat-African walnut cookies. Sky Journal of Food Science 5: 24-30.

Citation: Emem UH, Emelike NJT, Okorie-Humphrey C, Enyi CU (2024) Nutritional and Sensory Properties of Cookies Produced from Flour Blends of African Walnut (Tetracarpidium Conophorum), Justicia Carnea and Wheat. J Food Sci Nutr 10: 189.

Copyright: © 2024  Udedeh H Emem, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.


Herald Scholarly Open Access is a leading, internationally publishing house in the fields of Sciences. Our mission is to provide an access to knowledge globally.



© 2024, Copyrights Herald Scholarly Open Access. All Rights Reserved!